Invest for Long Term??

Excerpts from: http://www.theedgedaily.com/

“The Malaysian equity funds have posted "respectable returns" over the mid- to long-term periods, the Federation of Malaysian Unit Trust Managers (FMUTM). It said based on Standard & Poor's report on the fund performance as at July 28, 2006, the average returns for Malaysian equity funds for the seven-year period was 24%, five-year period 56% and three-year period 26%.”

Period (year) 3 5 7
UT Return (%) 26 56 24
UT CAGR (%) 8.01 9.30 3.12
FD Return with 4% CAGR (%) 12.49 21.67 31.59

As we can notice from the table above, by placing your money in unit trust (mutual fund) investment for 3 years, the return for the period would be 26% and when it translates to Compounded Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) which is 8.01. Similarly, for the period of 5 and 7 years, the return is 56% and 24% respectively and for CAGR for both, the former is 9.30% and the later is 3.12%. What will you get if you place your investment in “risk-free” Certificate of Deposit (CD) or known as Fixed Deposit (FD) in English Commonwealth countries? With 4% return annually, the figure will shock us!! For the period of 7 years, this “risk-free” investment performs better than unit trust (mutual fund) investment with more than 7%. When handling your hard-earned monies on hoping for better value creation by those fund managers, it seems that they do not fulfill your hope and as they promise – create value to its investors.



While the promoters of the unit trust investment always brainwash us “look for long term”, “let professionals handle your investment” and so forth, the reality is so cruel – it creates no value at all to the investors for longer term. When the promoters once again claim for the “outstanding” performance for 5 years period, bear in mind that the period is started from the 2001/02 market where it was the lowest. The best fund manager is not who gets the highest return when it is bull market, it is who gets the best result when it is bear market. It reminds me once again a famous quote by Warren Buffett: “It’s when the tide down, only you know who is swimming naked.”

Capital Guaranteed Fund III

Previous posts on Capital Guaranteed Fund:
Capital Guaranteed Fund I
Capital Guaranteed Fund II

Everybody aware of inflation. Due to this animal, $100 we have after a year (FUTURE VALUE) will not allowed you to purchase a same amount product which is quoted in today price (PRESENT VALUE). Giving 5% inflation rate per annum, your $100 of FUTURE VALUE (after a year) will only allowed you buy a product which is quoted today at $86.38 (PRESENT VALUE). Thus, after a 3 years maturity period, RM 300 million of FUTURE VALUE is equivalent to RM 259.15 million of PRESENT VALUE!! With capital guaranteed capped at RM 300 million (FUTURE VALUE) after 3 years, it’s for sure fund could deliver their capital guaranteed even their investment result is poor. They are left with RM 13.21 million (RM 272.36 million – RM 259.15 million) to play around even their investment result delivered no result at all for the entire 3 years period! That’s a “SURE CAPITAL GUARANTEED, ZERO RISK” Investment!!

The calculation above is simplified to an illustration purpose. The assumption made is there is no return (0%) for entire 3 years period.



When fund tagged with “Capital Guaranteed”, it should at least preserve its fund holders’ value. This means that for RM 300 million (PRESENT VALUE), it should at least appreciate to RM 347.29 million (FUTURE VALUE) to align with its tag of “Capital Guaranteed”. If RM 300 million (PRESENT VALUE) remain as RM 300 million (FUTURE VALUE), it actually deteriorates its fund holders’ value at the rate of 5% per annum! What’s the point for investors to invest into these funds if it serves no purpose at all. After all, they could place their money into bank’s Certificate of Deposit (CD) or Fixed Deposit (FD) to enjoy “Capital Guaranteed, Zero Risk” return. Currently, a FD depositor in Malaysia enjoys 3.7% return per annum. So, with RM 300 million (PRESENT VALUE), his account balance will show RM 334.55 million (FUTURE VALUE) after 3 years. That’s almost 35% difference!

What You See Is What You Get? III

As you notice, the difference of BP-BP and ROI decreases when the investment period is longer. From the table, you will shock to notice that you actually incur loss of 5.28% if you cash out after a year of investment. That means if you invest $ 10,000 at the beginning and cash out after a year, you only manage to get back $ 9,472!!

How about the return for Certificate of Deposit (CD) or known as Fixed Deposit (FD) in some countries? Assuming CD/FD could give you 4% return per annum, the return over 5 years period would be:

Year 4% return per annum ROI (%)
0 1 0
1 1.04 4
2 1.0816 8.16
3 1.1249 12.49
4 1.1699 16.99
5 1.2167 21.67



When you compare ROI of Fund KSA and CD/FD, you will notice that ROI of Fund KSA only outpaces CD/FD after 4th year!! Amazing, isn’t it? When you pay hoping for get the better return as compared to “risk-free” CD/FD investment, the outcome is shocking. That is no wonder, the promoters always ask you to invest for long term – the longer the better. We do agree that investment should always for long term (more than 7 years). But, this only applies to the investment that creates value to its investors. If you choose a lousy investment, the longer you hold, the worse you get. Time is unemotional, it would not sympathize you because you choose a lousy investment. In fact, time would punish you if you choose a lousy investment. Time only reward to those who choose a good investment, this is the core of the value investment.

Next time, when the promoters of Mutual Fund (Unit Trust) try to persuade you to purchase the fund and show you how good the return, you should ask them one question: the return is on whose perspective, Fund or investor, that’s you who pull out the money to feed them.

Good Investment III?

Before we put into conclusion, let see if we place $ 270,000 in bank’s Certificate of Deposit (CD, in US) or Fixed Deposit (FD, in UK) account which earn 4% per annum, how much will we get after 30 years? $ 875,717.33. At a glance, AP investment seems a good investment, isn’t it? Before we jump into a conclusion, let see what will we get if we invest in say BI investment that earn 15% per annum over 30 years period? The result? $ 1,787,717.84. What if we invest in KB investment that earns 20% per annum over the same period? $ 6,409,160.47!


We often hear the interested parties and the promoters of AP investment urging us to invest in AP. The reasoning given are we can use the power of leverage to maximize our investment, the value of AP is always going up, we only need to lay out the initial payment and the less is borned by our tenants….etc. We also been “brainwashed” decades by decades and we really believe that AP is really a good investment subconsciously. No matter how nice words put on the investment, business is business. At the end, businessman would look at his income statement, balance sheet…etc to determine whether it’s a good investment or not. By showing the example above, it’s obvious that the perception we have is totally out in term of the businessman point of view, that’s creating values to his initial capital investment. Ironically, most people still put their faith into AP investment. Are they ignorant? If one day, the investors realized the truth, will the market crash? The history will tell us the story. “The man who ignores history does not have his story.”

Finally, what’s AP investment? REAL ESTATE.